Last year on this date, I posted a seven-part series on the fall of the Berlin Wall, commemorating the 20th anniversary of that watershed event. Today, I reread the posts and was struck by what I wrote in the introduction, in light of recent events in the US. 

In spite of obvious physical and historical barriers between the two opposing political systems, one overran the other, almost overnight. The changeover was swift and bloodless.

I wrote:
As television viewers, we all know how easy it is to sway large groups of people, but still, it’s stunning how easily East German authorities convinced people that walls and borders were there to protect them from the immoral and dangerous influences of the West.

And:
In spite of all the available firepower, attack dogs, machine guns, landmines, barbed wire, Stasi and whatever else they threatened people with, not one single shot was fired on the night of November 9, 1989. 

Not long after der Berliner Mauerfall, citizens of Leipzig, Dresden and other eastern cities tested the waters and got the same response. Guards were either ambivalent about what to do, overwhelmed by the crowds or unwilling to stop them. 

In the case of the Berlin Wall, we join most of the world in applauding the coup, but we should never assume progressive movements will always be the ones that prevail.

I repost these excerpts with some hesitation, but urge you to revisit the series as a reminder (and warning!) of how easily the tide can change, even when the odds are against it, even in a democracy, even in this day and age:
http://www.birdsonawireblog.com/1/category/fall%20of%20the%20berlin%20wall/1.html

 


Comments

11/09/2010 11:52

In a heartbeat, and students of history know that it really can happen here and now. That's why some of my friends are organizing to emigrate. But where? They say, to Europe, but the news changes daily there, too. Perhaps to Atlantis.

It cuts both ways, though, those sudden changes. What was that saying P. T. Barnum had? "You can fool some of the people all of the time and all of the people some of the time, but you cannot fool all of the people all of the time." To which my hero, James Thurber, responded, "You can fool too many of the people too much of the time.

Thank you for the series!

Reply
paula
11/10/2010 08:03

Let's hope it doesn't come to emigration, but I've considered that route before. I don't think many of us would be welcome in parts of Europe, but maybe I'm wrong about that. As long as you're not planning to work (other than for yourself), maybe you'd be welcomed, especially if you brought your own health insurance. I'm not sure how a US citizen could do that, but it might be worth looking into.
Atlantis sounds better and better. Bring your swim fins.

Reply
11/19/2010 00:50

The other night saw an unsettling film, "DDR/DDR" on how East Germans felt about the wall down--soon after it happened. The Stassi were very awful, the people were constantly under surveilance (as in that other film, "The Lives of Others.")

Post film talk with film's writer/producer centered on how little we ask in U.S. about increasing watchfulness of us in many places.

I too want to be upbeat bout future for my kids, grandkids but so much of what I see in the culture--focus on the inane/entertaining-- does not support my fondest wishes.

Reply
paula
11/28/2010 17:26

You make a good point, Naomi. It's important for us to help our kids deal with the reality of today's U.S., even when we don't like what we see. Is that two-faced? Maybe a little, but it's also true we love this place and want it to be all it can be for us, our kids and grandkids.
As for the Stasi and surveillance, I can't imagine it ever getting that bad here, even under conservative rule. What I saw in East Germany made my skin crawl. I couldn't wait to get out of there.

Reply



Leave a Reply